My Heart Will Move On


 

 

This scene is the most emotionally packed three minutes of one of the best-selling movies in history. It’s the final death of a star-crossed lover pulled from Rose by society and a tragic event. It’s the moment when even the most virile of men are happy they’re in a dark room because their eyes may start to tear up. It’s a moment when one may question how important economic status is when true love is involved.

However, when I watch this emotionally packed scene, I think of only one thing: Jack totally could have fit on that board.

James Cameron’s one little factual slip up ruined the whole premise of the story and dampened any strong emotions I may have felt throughout the movie.

Mike Daisey’s innumerable factual slip-ups have the same effect on his theatrical monologue, “The Agony and the Ecstasy of Steve Jobs.”

I am a firm believer that humans are social creatures. We learn best through stories and anecdotes. Our senses of empathy and sympathy, which are evoked through these tales, move us to great extents to amazing distances for fellow man. Novelists, poets, musicians and play-writes are masters of breaking the complex and confusing world into a chapter, a stanza, a melody or an act so the audiences can better understand the problems, which prevail in our world today. However, a small crack in credibility can ruin even one of the most successful films in history, and it can certainly ruin a play that is a social commentary.

One of Mike Daisey’s most poignant scenes came when he described men that could not even pick up a glass because their hands were shaking from n-hexane poisoning. Did anyone stop to check whether shaking is a symptom of n-hexane? According to the Chronic Toxicity Summary of the substance from the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment of California, it is not. While there are many effects, they are generally loss of motor function, and not erratic movements. Not only did Mike Daisey not meet these people, he did not even come up with a credible lie. This factual flaw, not even mentioned by This American Life, broke the emotional attachment I had to the story, and thus my sense of empathy and my desire to take a stand for a social change.

By not using the correct facts in his social commentary, Mike Daisey completely failed to reach his goal of inspiring the masses to boycott Apple products until working conditions in Chinese factories improved, just like James Cameron failed his goal of making me cry when I noticed that Jack could have fit on the board.

Advertisements

3 responses to “My Heart Will Move On

  1. I like what you did here by comparing the monologue to the Titanic, and agree with your point that small discrepencies can ruin a performance. His lies inevitably do take away the power of his work. In the end however I think that the monologue still has value, and that value is in the fact that it started a lot of discussion. In order for him to be proven false, people had to care about what he said. They had to do research. They had to become socially aware. I think that just because in the end, his work was discredited doesn’t mean it didn’t have an overall positive impact on society.

  2. I really enjoyed the analogy you made in this piece. I believe that the reference to James Cameron’s “Titanic” really helped illustrate the point you were trying to make, a point that I definitely agree with. One obvious misstep can ruin the legitimacy of an entire piece. When someone tries too hard to be dramatic and make a point, it can take away from the overall message. That is what James Cameron and Mike Daisey have in common. Both tried to make something too dramatic and, in turn, it took away from the legitimacy of the piece. I agree that Daisey’s lies took away from the validity of the monologue, but am not convinced that it ruined his message. He wanted people to be aware, and now they definitely are.

  3. I actually love your analogy. I completely agree that Mr. Daisey may have had a much more compelling argument to boycott apple’s products, but the issue was that after the fabrications were discovered, the focus was no longer on the facts and the injustices occurring at the factory, but now were just about how he is a liar. I cannot justify his lies as “trying to get attention” for the cause. His lies were absolutely absurd and he deserves to be punished.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s